Sydney McGee

Chef Sydney McGee is the Executive Chef of Forsythia – an intimate Roman-inspired Italian restaurant on New York City’s Lower East Side, rooted in handmade pasta, seasonal cooking, and warm hospitality. In this conversation with Chef Sydney, she shares some of the experiences that shaped her as a chef, why she loves being a part of Forsythia, how she finds menu inspiration, and so much more! Follow her journey on Instagram.


Your love of cooking started at a young age, bringing your family together around the dinner table. How have those early experiences, along with your grandmother’s influence, shaped the chef you are today? 

Cooking started with the desire to bring my family together. We were not a “sit down at the dinner table every night” kind of family. Growing up in North Carolina, I started grocery shopping and making dinner for my family as soon as I could drive. It was my way of getting everyone around the table at the same time. 

It grew into a passion my dad and I shared. My grandmother was also a huge influence on me. The way she cooks is with such intention. She taught me the importance of quality ingredients, knowing where your food comes from, and always questioning how to make things better. She taught me to work in an organized, clean way. She taught me that I could do hard things. Those are things I still think about every day in the kitchen. 

You’ve worked at acclaimed New York restaurants like Don Angie and San Sabino and spent time cooking in Lucca, Italy. What are some of the most valuable lessons you’ve taken from those experiences? 

I’ve been really lucky to learn from some incredible chefs early in my career. Working with Angie Rito and Adam Richardson taught me so much about discipline, consistency, and holding yourself to a high standard. Spending time in Italy was also an eye-opening experience. It deepened my love for Italian cooking and taught me to value ingredients, tradition, and culture. I try to bring a little bit of everything I’ve learned into what we’re doing at Forsythia. 


You first discovered Forsythia as a guest and knew immediately that you wanted to be part of it. What drew you to the restaurant, and how has your vision evolved now that you’re leading the kitchen as Executive Chef? 

I actually came into Forsythia for dinner with a friend who also works in the industry the night before I left for Italy for the first time. I remember thinking, “This is exactly the kind of restaurant I’d want to open one day.” I loved the food, the atmosphere, and the approach to Italian cooking. 

After spending time in Italy, I knew I wanted to work here. It was the closest restaurant I could find to true Italian cooking, both in the food and the work environment. There was passion here. Chef-Owner Jacob Siwak has given me so much support and creative freedom, and I’m really excited about where we’re taking the restaurant. My goal is to keep building on what makes Forsythia special while bringing my own perspective to the menu. 


Pasta is such an important part of Forsythia’s identity. What makes a truly great pasta dish, and is there a particular shape or preparation you love working with?

A truly great pasta dish is one where the shape and sauce work together. For example, every fall we do pappardelle al cinghiale. This year, we decided to do pappardelle ruvida. This preparation involves sheeting the pasta about 75% of the way, letting it dry slightly, and then finishing the sheeting process. This creates small cracks in the pasta, allowing the sauce to really latch onto it. It’s a strong pappardelle that holds up well to the layers of ragù. 

Personally, I love nothing more than sitting down and making handmade pasta shapes. Every week, my sous chef and I, along with whoever wants to join us, sit down and hand-shape our tortelli. It’s a special moment to bond, teach, and relax. Pasta is at the core of everything I love and at the core of Forsythia. 

Your cooking is rooted in Italian tradition, seasonality, and quality ingredients. How do you balance respecting classic Italian recipes with bringing your own creativity and personality to the menu? 

II think the best Italian food starts with really good ingredients and letting them speak for themselves. I know this is a common statement, but Italian cooking really is about reduction. The shock factor you can achieve by putting three things on a plate and having them truly shine is incomparable. 

We are very careful about where we source our ingredients. I’m not interested in making something complex just for the sake of being different or innovative. I really don’t ever want my cooking to be about me; it’s about Italy. I want to get as close to Italy as I can and bring people with me. 

I want people to take a bite and think, “Wow, that’s delicious,” and then continue to enjoy their meal with the people they’re with. There’s so much room to be creative while still respecting the traditions behind a dish. For me, it’s about finding that balance and making food people genuinely want to eat. 

What’s one underrated ingredient you think deserves more attention in the kitchen, and how do you like to use it? 

I love salt, as many chefs do. What I really love is finding different ways to incorporate salt. Roman cooking has a lot of beautiful salty ingredients like Pecorino Romano and guanciale. On this theme, I think an underutilized ingredient is capers. I get salt-packed capers from Pantelleria that have both a beautiful flavor and a natural saltiness that boosts so many sauces and dishes. 

When developing a new dish, where do you typically find inspiration? Is there a particular dish on Forsythia’s menu right now that you’re especially proud of? 

I find inspiration in so many different places. In the warmer months, I’ll often start with produce. Other times, I start with my books. Sometimes, I start something and it leads me in a completely different direction. 

A good example is our Pizette Fritte, which joined our menu this summer and will continue to evolve as the seasons change. Originally, I had a panzanella on the menu. I love panzanella from my time working in Tuscany, but I started to get a little bored of it this year. Tomato season was particularly long, so I began thinking of another way to use these beautiful fresh tomatoes.

One day, I was craving tomato toast and wanted to find a way to make it for the menu. We make fresh focaccia every day, but focaccia isn’t great for toast. So I started thinking about another bread I could make. This is where reality becomes a huge part of R&D. It wasn’t feasible for our team to make another long-fermentation bread. I needed something quick. 

That led me to pizette, a dough I could make and serve the same day. So I made it. I was waiting for the dough to rest and got impatient, so instead of baking the pizzette as planned, I threw them in the fryer to see what would happen. They puffed beautifully and had great flavor. 

Pizette fritte in Naples have such a wonderful history, and I decided to do my own take on the dish. Instead of the tomato that’s often baked into pizzette, I topped the fried dough with a robiolina whip seasoned with fresh herbs and a thick slice of fresh tomato that I handpicked from the farmers market to be the perfect size for these little pizzette. 

I know it’s a long story, but I think it really demonstrates how you can start somewhere and end up somewhere completely different. Tomato toast became our Pizette Fritte, which is now one of my favorite dishes. I also introduced a special flour from Sicily that I love. 

The thing that’s most important to me is staying connected to Italy throughout the whole process, staying connected to a story and the ingredients. If I do that, I know I’ll stay on the right path and end up somewhere beautiful. 


You’ve stepped into an Executive Chef role relatively early in your career. What’s been the biggest learning curve in leading a kitchen, and how would you describe your leadership style? 

I did not expect to be in this position this early in my career. I’m still learning every single day, and I think that’s one of the most exciting parts of this job. I think that’s also how I got here. I never stopped pushing myself into the roles above me because I couldn’t help but be involved in every step. 

Being a chef isn’t just about cooking great food. I’ve always been drawn to restaurants, not just cooking. It’s about understanding your team, figuring out how to bring out the best in everyone, and creating an environment where people actually enjoy coming to work. 

I’ve been fortunate to work with chefs who taught me a lot about leadership, and I try to lead with patience while still holding everyone, including myself, to a high standard. I want to be the kind of chef I’d want to work for. 

I try my best to really understand everyone who works with me as an individual and help them grow while leaning into their strengths. I really encourage self-sufficiency and critical thinking in my cooks. I want people to learn how to cook, not just how to follow directions. I want people to develop strong problem-solving skills, confidence, and knowledge.


Italian cooking often celebrates simplicity. What’s one dish that seems easy to make but is actually incredibly difficult to perfect? 

A staple on our menu is our Cacio e Pepe Supplì. The first step of this dish is making risotto, a notoriously difficult technique to perfect. We make a large batch of risotto each week, but the trick is to undercook it just slightly so that when it’s fried, it finishes cooking and the individual texture of the rice remains. It also has to have the perfect liquid content to be shaped without being too dry or too wet. 

This is a classic example of a dish that can’t rely entirely on a recipe. Yes, we have a rough recipe we follow for ratios, but the process itself is 75% intuition. 

Then comes the shaping. One member of our team, Cande, has worked at Forsythia since it opened, and she makes all of our supplì. They need to be shaped and stuffed with mozzarella di bufala in just the right way so there’s enough cheese, but not so much that it breaks through the outside layer of rice. And they all need to look the same. 

It’s a difficult production process, but at the end of the day, it eats like a rice ball stuffed with cheese. It’s just rice and cheese. 

What advice would you give to young chefs looking to grow their careers and eventually lead their own kitchens? 

Not dissimilarly to what I was told coming up in this career – work hard and take care of yourself. This is not an easy career, but I would also never discourage someone from pursuing it – as I was many times told. One of my first mentors told me the most important thing I can do is take care of my body because it is going to work very hard for me. I think setting the expectation early that this career is difficult is not necessarily negative but just very realistic. There is so much beauty in the difficult parts of this career. The relationships I have formed, the amount I have learned about myself, how to manage my happiness, and what it feels like to really work hard for something is very rewarding. Because of the nature of the job, truly the best piece of advice I could give, is to take care of yourself physically and mentally. It is vital to running a kitchen and sustaining the joy of what we do. I will also add the caveat that this takes time to figure out and balance. So, give yourself grace along the way. Find what works for you and what is too much. 

Looking ahead, what are you most excited about for the next chapter of Forsythia? 

From the moment I started working at Forsythia, I had the immediate impression that we were only scratching the surface of what we were going to accomplish. I am so immensely grateful for the team that I work with and what we have accomplished so far. What I am excited for is everything that I believe we are yet to accomplish and most importantly, soaking in each step on the way there. I am excited to grow my relationship with the people here, my community, myself, and Italy.